Monday 23 June 2008

Cultural Sites in Greece

Sharon Waxman has drawn attention to an article, "Run-down heritage sites embarrass the Greeks" by Helena Smith, in The Guardian (June 23, 2008). This discusses the issue of access to world-heritage status archaeological sites.

There is a quote from Michali Liapis, the minister of culture:
The situation at museums and sites around the country is bad ...It has to be corrected.
Maria Damanaki, the shadow minister of culture, was interviewed for The Guardian report:
What we are seeing is the indifference of a government that simply does not make culture a priority.
Waxman takes a strong position on this:
Countries like Greece cannot justifiably demand the return of objects taken in recent decades by looters, or a century ago by imperial-minded "collectors," if they cannot adequately care for the objects and sites they already have. But reality is a harsh taskmaster. Caring for antiquities costs money. The answer lies not in pointing fingers, as is suggested by the article in the Guardian. The answer - the only possible answer - lies in recognition that the responsibility for preservation lies with us all. That concern, the concern over preservation, must take precedence over the issue of possession.

It seems to me that there are several issues here:
  1. Access to internationally important archaeological sites.
  2. Ability for a worldwide public to view key archaeological finds.
  3. The protection of yet unexcavated archaeological sites.
Waxman is perhaps a little too foreceful in her comments, but Liapis needs to address these perceptions.

Image
Rhamnous © David Gill

2 comments:

Rachel said...

As someone who recently visited Greece I have to say that sites across Greece have to be better protected. In Gortyn my father and I were practically forced to walk on pottery shards to view the Temple of Apollo. At one point my father reached down and picked up the handle to a piece of pottery. The piece was about 4 inches long and just sitting in the walking path, next to dozens of additional smaller fragments. It was a disheartening experience.

David Gill said...

Rachel
Thank you for these comments. The Hellenic Ministry of Culture has responsibility for hundreds of archaeological sites - many of them managed for visits by tens of thousands of tourists. Gortyn is an extensive site (the area round the church and the inscription is one tiny corner) occupied over a long period of time.
Best wishes
David

The Stern Collection in New York: Cycladic or Cycladicising?

Courtesy of Christos Tsirogiannis There appears to be excitement about the display of 161 Cycladicising objects at New York's Metropolit...